2011 FINALISTS:
- Winner: Alison Summy - Ethel's Pink Beauty
- Pro Division Winner: Dinah Grossman from Cheap Tart Bakery
- 2nd Place: Adrienne Smith - Plain and Simple
- 3rd Place: Kathy Rice - Pi Squared
- 4th Place: Laura Kaminski - Apple Pie Eyed
- 5th Place: Joan Elias - Bessie's Best Pie
- 6th Place: Vanessa Rancine - Break Me Off a Piece of That!
- 7th Place Marc Chibnik - Chubby Chibby
- 8th Place: Meggan Christensen - You Down with A.P.P.L.E.P.I.E.
- 2011 Semi-Finalists (in alphabetical order):
- Alanna Elinoff - Alfred
- Alexandra Huckabay - Pie in the Eye
- Anna Fehsenfeld - Aunt Nieme's Apple Pie
- Carly Berard - Autumn Apple Pie
- Christine Strom - Strum's Joie de Tarte Aux Pommes
- Daisy Varughese - Daisy's Tasty Chai Apple Pie
- Daniel Kenis - Maple-Caramel Apple Pie with Pecan-Pastry Crust
- Ellen Magin & Ray Reiss - B&B Pie
- Hollyce Cervantes - Grandma Helen's Divine Apple Pie
- Jennifer Mitchell - Apple Jack
- Jill Persin - Nothin' Fancy Apple Pie
- Jillian Dorrestein - Apples & Spice & Everything Nice
- Rachel Roszmann - Hog Wild Pie
- Rob Hunter - Grandma's Dream
- Russel McGonagle - Betty Pie
- Sue Cortesi - Spiced Autumn Apple Pie
- Taryn, Della & Luke Westra - Treehouse Pie
- Vanessa LeWinter, Rebecca Bradley, Halley Guren, Emily Bourassa & Megan Dunn - The Comeback
- William Barge - ln(-1)/i
- Zoe Benway - I'm No Tart
